Twenty-five conditions, covering materials, 1:10 window reveals, conservation rooflights and the trees. The decision was issued four days before the first lockdown. Eighteen months later the site was sold with the permission, and the buyer built the consented scheme.
The full story
The first scheme, submitted in November 2018, drew 30 objections from 26 residents. Officers shared the concern: too tall, too dense, too dominant for the conservation area. Historic England asked for the scale to come down. Underneath the heritage case sat two more problems. The site was allocated for employment, and its viability report showed it could not carry the affordable housing and Section 106 contributions a major application normally brings.
The case officer was willing to work with us, and over two rounds of amendment we rebuilt the scheme around what the street could accept. The Victorian house at 2 Castilian Street, first proposed for demolition, was kept and converted to two townhouses. The single block wrapping the corner was split in two, re-opening the view through to the mews behind. The Derngate building came down to four storeys reading as three with a roof, its parapets, chimneys and inset dormers taken from the adjacent terraces, its windows set back for shadow. When the amended scheme went back out, the 30 objections became six, and Historic England wrote that the buildings no longer appeared out of scale and overly dominant.
In parallel we supported the viability case. The council's own independent assessor reached the same conclusion as the applicant's viability report, even on a lower profit margin: the scheme could only be delivered without affordable housing or Section 106 contributions. The officer's report weighed that against homes on a long-vacant brownfield site, and the council, which could not show a five-year housing land supply at the time, came down in favour of the homes.
The committee granted full permission on 17 March 2020 and the notice followed two days later. In September 2021 the site was sold to a regional developer with the permission, and the scheme was built over 2022 and 2023 to the consented design. The townhouses are now a gated mews in the Cultural Quarter. Our work ended at the decision. The buyer's own team delivered it.